Interactive comment on “Linear and Non-linear Stability Analysis of the Rate and State Friction Model with Three State Variables” by N. Sinha and A
نویسنده
چکیده
In this paper, the authors have analyzed the quasi-static frictional sliding of a springblock slider system under the Rate-State Friction (RSF) formalism with three state variables. The study of 3-state RSF systems have not been carried out in the literature, the authors claim that this warrants the study of mechanical behavior of such systems. I feel that that this is not justifiable scientific motivation. There is good reason why 3-state variable systems have not been studied in the literature, laboratory friction experiments simply do not seem to suggest the need for this additional complexity. While some large rate-step experiments seem to point towards a second state variable (Marone, 1998; Ruina 1983) even this, in itself, is by no means a robust feature of experimental rate-stepping data. I find it difficult to understand the need for adding yet
منابع مشابه
Interactive comment on “Linear and Non-linear Stability Analysis of the Rate and State Friction Model with Three State Variables” by N. Sinha and A. K. Singh
In this paper, the authors have analyzed the quasi-static frictional sliding of a springblock slider system under the Rate-State Friction (RSF) formalism with three state variables. The study of 3-state RSF systems have not been carried out in the literature, the authors claim that this warrants the study of mechanical behavior of such systems. I feel that that this is not justifiable scientifi...
متن کاملLinear and Non - linear Stability Analysis of the Rate and State Friction 1 Model with Three State Variables
متن کامل
Estimating Stock Price in Energy Market Including Oil, Gas, and Coal: The Comparison of Linear and Non-Linear Two-State Markov Regime Switching Models
A common method to study the dynamic behavior of macroeconomic variables is using linear time series models; however, they are unable to explain nonlinear behavior of the series. Given the dependency between stock market and derivatives, the behavior of the underlying asset price can be modeled using Markov switching process properties and the economic regime significance. In this paper, a two-...
متن کاملNew evidence for the relationship between government size and economic growth in Iran: an application for a three-regime Non-linear threshold regression model
abstract: Over the past two centuries, the role of government and the composition of government spending have changed in most countries of the world. Theoretically, there is no consensus among economists about the size of the state and the degree of state interference in the economy. On the one hand, one can observe classics and market's proponents who believe in a small government and little ...
متن کاملNon-linear Analysis of Stability in the Islamic Banking Industry
Stability analysis is one of the most important fields of study in the Islamic banking and finance industry. For measuring stability in Islamic banking, we introduced, for the first time, an Islamic banking stability index (IBS) during 2013 to 2016 which use all CAMEL factors and so seems to be more comprehensive than Z-score stability index which dominantly used in the existing literatures. To...
متن کامل